The North Star Flag
A PROPOSAL FOR A NEW MINNESOTA STATE FLAG
1849 - TERRITORIAL SEAL.
The territorial seal was designed by Capt. Seth Eastman at the request of Gov. Alexander Ramsey and Delegate Henry Sibley. Eastman's wife wrote a poem about the seal in which she described the westward flight (into the sunset) of the Indian from the pioneer in Minnesota. These sentiments would cause controversies over the seal in the 1960's. The seal was mistakenly engraved in reverse.
1858 - STATE SEAL.
The bill for a completely new state seal seems to have been "mislaid" by Henry Sibley, who simply modified his territorial seal --- an arrangement confirmed by law in 1861. Sibley created a new motto for the state seal: "L'etoile du nord" -- which is French for "the North Star." In 1881, the seal was re-cast (with minor changes) after a fire at the Capitol.
1861-65 - CIVIL WAR BATTLE FLAGS.
In keeping with Union custom, several Minnesota regiments carried blue regimental colors with the state seal in the center, including the 1st Minnesota (which fought at Gettysburg), and the 2nd, 4th, and 5th Minnesota. Most other Minnesota regimental flags, however, had the American eagle in the center, in accordance with federal regulations. Minnesota's regimental colors are today displayed in the Capitol rotunda on a rotating basis.
1893 - FIRST STATE FLAG.
In 1893, the Minnesota delegation to the Chicago World's Fair held a contest (under the auspices of the state legislature) to design a "Minnesota State Flag." The flag would serve as a promotional tool for the state at its exhibition pavilion in Chicago, and had to include various features, including the state seal. The latter may have been influenced by Minnesota's Civil War regimental flags, or by existing state flags elsewhere, or both. Amelia Hyde Center of Minneapolis submitted the winning entry: a white flag with the state seal, framed by other symbols. The reverse of her flag was blue. It became law on April 4; but because of its complexity, it was rarely reproduced for actual use. (Cf. "The Origin of the Minnesota State Flag: A Theory")
1957 - SECOND STATE FLAG.
Infrequent use of the state flag and complaints about its bulk and expense caused the legislature to simplify its design, in preparation for the state centennial (1958). A 1955 law established an interim committee to work out the details. The new flag became law in 1957. Both sides of the new state flag were blue, with the reverse side being a mirror-image of the obverse. Citing problems with the committee's ideas, several legislators had instead proposed a completely new design which was red, white, and blue, with gold stars. Chief among these legislators was Rep. John Tracy Anderson, who presented a design drafted by the-then adjutant general.
1983 - THIRD STATE FLAG.
In 1968, the State Human Rights Commissioner asked the Secretary of State to have the state seal changed, because of complaints that it portrayed the flight of the Indian from the pioneer. The request was considered inopportune. However, in 1971 the Secretary of State (on his own initiative) introduced a new seal in which the fleeing Indian was replaced by a pioneer on horseback. This seal was never used on the state flag. Then, in 1983, a new law restored the Indian to the seal, and standardized the seal's exact design, since many small differences had become evident in its various renditions. In the new design, the Indian rides toward the south (rather than westward), in response to the earlier concerns of civil rights advocates. The new seal results in the third version of the state flag.
1989 - PROPOSAL FOR A NEW FLAG.
In 1989, a citizens' coalition began to campaign for a new flag, in time for the centennial of the first state flag (1993). They also proposed the use of the current flag as a ceremonial standard for state executive officers. Two hearings were held in the House Governmental Operations Committee under the bi-partisan sponsorship of Rep. Wayne Simoneau and Rep. Gil Gutknecht (one in March and one in September). The House leadership did not permit the study to continue. Nevertheless, the proposal received numerous endorsements from international flag experts, including one who co-designed the flag of Canada. Endorsements also came from state newspaper editors, including the editors of the Minneapolis Star-Tribune. The Saint Paul Pioneer Press even held a "contest" for a new state flag. The proposal of the citizens' coalition, whose design is featured throughout these pages, was based on the following international standards for flag design:
A. To Espouse Minnesota's Ideals: the flag's message must be timeless; it must use traditional colors and symbols; its message must be unifying.
B. To Identify our State: it must have a proper graphic form; it must communicate well at a distance; one must be able to remember its design/meaning; it must be easily distinguished from other flags.
C. To Be Widely Used: it should not be too costly; it should be manipulable (in various shapes, sizes); it should admit of exact legal standardization.
2001 - EXPERTS RATE MINNESOTA FLAG AS POOR.
A national organization of flag scholars, the North American Vexillological Association, published a survey in which experts rate Minnesota's current flag as one of the ten worst designs in the U.S. and Canada. The expert survey judged flag designs according to their visibility at a distance, and effective use of pattern and symbol. News organizations widely reported the study. (Some confusion was caused by media characterizations of the worst designs as "ugly." Beauty, of course, is always in the eyes of the beholder; the study instead rated the flags according to standards of effective design.) The study bolsters legislative efforts to change the flag.
2000s - ONGOING PROPOSALS FOR A NEW STATE FLAG.
Since 2000, legislative bills to study redesigning the state flag have been introduced several times. Senator Edward Oliver was the first to introduce a bill, and he held press conferences. The same basic bill has been filed seven times: in 2000, 2002 (where it passed in House committee but failed in Senate committee), 2006 (where it passed in Senate committee only), 2007, 2010, 2018 (as reported on PBS), and most recently in 2019 in both the House and Senate.
QUESTIONS RAISED BY THE HISTORY▪ The state flag has been in use for over a century (despite alterations), and may have roots in some Minnesota battle flags carried in the Civil and Dakota Wars. Does this make its tradition inviolable? When does a flag-design enjoy a "living tradition" as opposed to "heirloom" status?
of the Minnesota state flag and seal:
▪ The seal on the flag originally celebrated the "manifest destiny" of the white man to replace the Indian on the frontier as the U.S. spread westward. What does this history mean for the future of the flag? Should a flag propose socio-political ideals for the future, or instead commemorate actual history (even controversial aspects)?
▪ In 1983 the legislature rearranged the figures to suggest harmony among the races. Can a legislative decree actually redefine the original meaning of the seal and flag?
▪ The state flag has its origins in a small painting; namely, a watercolor of a pioneer and Indian on the frontier. Do paintings make good flags, or do flags comprise a different artistic medium?
▪ Three different versions of the flag have been in force since 1893, due to modifications of its design elements. Have these changes made it a successful symbol of Minnesota for the future?
For more: in addition to the links above, see
William M. Becker, "The Origin of the Minnesota State Flag," Minnesota History (Spring 1992), 2-8 & 41.
David Gillette, “Redesigning Minnesota’s State Flag,” TPT Almanac, News Video, Twin Cities Public Television, March 28, 2018.
Minnesota Legislature, "Minnesota State Symbols," Official Website.